Baker Academic

Was Rudolf Bultmann's impact on biblical studies generally positive or generally negative?

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Public Retraction Concerning Luther's Anti-Judaism - Le Donne

Almost every Paul course I've taught has included a class devoted to Luther's anti-Judaism. Today I must apologize for a statement about Luther that turns out to be misleading. I have, in these contexts, spoken of the "early Luther" and the "later Luther" concerning his anti-Judaism. The early Luther (or so I thought) seems to have more respect for the kinsmen of Jesus. Although, I suggest in this work that it was Luther's intention to proselytize that fueled his superficial respect.

I no longer think that a distinction between the young Luther and the man he became is helpful. His Dictata super Psalterium marks his early career and is laced with anti-Judaism. So it turns out that the man was a total arse on this topic, pretty much his whole life (sans a short lapse into veiled respect).

In sum, and in retraction, Luther = total arse on the topic of Judaism. I would use stronger language, but that would be a move more befitting of Luther.

-anthony

4 comments:

  1. perhaps reading an actual scholar of luther might help-

    http://www.eerdmans.com/Products/6676/martin-luthers-antisemitism.aspx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Always edified by your retorts Zwingli.

      I've been reading Brooks Schramm among others... as well as Luther himself.

      -anthony

      Delete
    2. "Total arse." Words to ponder.

      Delete

Note: all comments are moderated by an anonymous third party.