Last week action star Chuck Norris (and his wife) made news with a political ad containing a "dog whistle" remark. In this context, a dog whistle is a phrase that is too vague to be understood by "outsiders" but makes a statement of ideological solidarity for "insiders".
The phrase that caused the stir was made by his wife, Gena. After quoting the (now) iconic Ronald Reagan, Gena Norris claims that Americans will send their children on the "first step to a thousand years of darkness" if they re-elect President Obama. You can view the full ad here; see especially the statements made from 1:40 to 2:00.
After reading several network reports and blogs on this statement, it became clear to me that this dog whistle was especially effective. Very few national reporters or political analysts were able to decipher what she was talking about. Keith Olbermann (who takes himself way too seriously for a former ESPN anchor) was convinced that "darkness" was a racial dog whistle in reference to Obama's "blackness". Others suggested that the phrase was hyperbole connoting a possible era of American socialism. But the contextualization necessary to understand this phrase is Revelation 20:1-7.
The interpreter who came closest to the mark suggested that the Bible predicts that Satan will reign for 1000 years before the apocalypse. But this isn't quite right since it is Christ who will reign for 1000 years, not Satan. This had me perplexed. Was Gena Norris drawing from some other tradition which taught that the antichrist would rule for 1000 years?
It wasn't until I read the KJV of Rev 20:3 that it occurred to me: "And cast him [the Devil/Satan] into the bottomless pit, and shut him up, and set a seal upon him, that he should deceive the nations no more, till the thousand years should be fulfilled: and after that he must be loosed a little season."
The imagery is obvious enough: Satan will be shut up in the pit (i.e. darkness) during this 1000 year rule of Christ. Could it be that the Norris's are saying that folks who vote for Obama will be sending their children into the abyss with Satan?
What interests me most is the eschatology implicit in this claim... somehow, voting Americans can force God's hand into fulfilling Revelation 20. Are we to believe that voting republicans can stay God's hand?
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
It's time to jettison the criterion of Semitic Influence
While I think that some of the traditional authenticity criteria might have a place in future Jesus research, I have been convinced that the two-sided criterion of Semitic Influence / Semitisms is beyond repair. The basic idea was that evidence of Aramaic or Hebrew influence in the Greek Gospel traditions betrays the words of Jesus. Otherwise, we might just be reading words attributed to Jesus by a Greek-speaking christian a generation later. While I adapt this criterion in my Historiographical Jesus and use it in conjunction with a broader method, I have now abandoned hope that this criterion can be rehabilitated. I was turned around by the monograph of Sang-il Lee. I was fortunate enough to read an early version of his dissertation written under the supervision of Loren Stuckenbruck. Stuckenbruck's chapter in Jesus, Criteria, and the Demise of Authenticity touches on Lee's topic, but also expands the argument. Stuckenbruck systematically deconstructs the premises upon which this criterion is based. I write a synopsis of Stuckenbruck's chapter in the introduction:
Chris and I knew that Loren's chapter would be a home run. But even with high expectations, we were positively giddy when we read his essay for the first time. It was kind of like watching an expert demolition crew implode Yankee Stadium in a matter of moments. We will be excited to have Prof. Stuckenbruck all the way from Munich for our conference in Dayton.
anthony
Chris and I knew that Loren's chapter would be a home run. But even with high expectations, we were positively giddy when we read his essay for the first time. It was kind of like watching an expert demolition crew implode Yankee Stadium in a matter of moments. We will be excited to have Prof. Stuckenbruck all the way from Munich for our conference in Dayton.
anthony
Tuesday, September 11, 2012
Monday, September 10, 2012
My chapter in Soundings in the Religion of Jesus - Le Donne
Together with Bruce Chilton and Jacob Neusner, I have co-edited a book that uses historical Jesus research as a platform for Jewish-Christian dialogue. According to the fine people at Fortress Press, advanced copies are newly available. You'd think that there would tons out there on this topic, but there is really very little.
In addition to writing the introduction for this book, I also write a chapter on the intellectual history of Jesus research. This chapter draws from the research done for my essay in JSHJ. My basic thesis is that the First Quest/No Quest/New Quest/Third Quest paradigm is ultimately misleading. This paradigm has roots in Albert Schweitzer's "quest" survey. While it was the best treatment of the topic at the time, it is time to recognize it for what it was: ethnocentric to the point of German, supremacist myopia. Indeed, Schweitzer calls German intelligentsia spiritually superior on the first pages.
In addition to writing the introduction for this book, I also write a chapter on the intellectual history of Jesus research. This chapter draws from the research done for my essay in JSHJ. My basic thesis is that the First Quest/No Quest/New Quest/Third Quest paradigm is ultimately misleading. This paradigm has roots in Albert Schweitzer's "quest" survey. While it was the best treatment of the topic at the time, it is time to recognize it for what it was: ethnocentric to the point of German, supremacist myopia. Indeed, Schweitzer calls German intelligentsia spiritually superior on the first pages.
“It is a quest and not a conquest”: The Historical Jesus at the British New Testament Conference—Chris Keith
This past week was the British New
Testament Conference. I could attend
only on Friday, but the seminar on the Historical Jesus was fantastic that
day.
The first session included presentations
from Brendon Witte and Mark Batluck, both PhD students at the University of
Edinburgh. As far as I could tell, both
were more focused on the Gospel texts than the historical Jesus per se. Witte argued that Jesus’ interaction with the
scribe in Matt. 8.18-20 underscores that Jesus’ identity is more along the lines
of a prophet than a “teacher” as the scribe had assumed. Batluck argued that the Gospel narratives
reveal an interesting phenomenon—although many scholars assume that revelatory
experiences were crucial to early Christianity, in the narratives themselves,
revelatory experiences do not produce faith commitments on the part of the
characters (with an exception here or there).
Both received some critical feedback, as always happens, but, as a proud
Edinburgh alumnus, I was happy to see the school well represented.
Edinburgh was also well represented in the
second session, which saw a current PhD student, Michael Zolondek, sit on a
panel with Larry Hurtado, Justin Meggitt, Catrin Williams, and Dagmar
Winter. The topic was the status quaestionis of Historical Jesus
studies. Hurtado exposed a common
assumption in motivations for Jesus studies; namely that the (theological)
validity of later Christian claims about Jesus’ identity is necessarily linked
to how Jesus thought about himself.
Catrin Williams reported on the John, Jesus, and History project. She noted that lack of clear methodology was
limiting its progress. Justin Meggitt
and Michael Zolondek both offered general comments on method in historical
Jesus studies, and addressed the criteria of authenticity. Zolondek argued that, in addition to the
criteria being a bad idea, debate about the criteria is a bad idea and
“hurting” Jesus studies. I had to laugh
a bit internally that he was making this point in the midst of participating in
the debate, but found much of what he said sympathetic with the focus of our
upcoming conference.
By far the most interesting presentation
for me in this session was that of Dagmar Winter, who also contributed to Jesus, Criteria, and the Demise of
Authenticity and will be in Dayton for the conference. She said she can’t see a point in the future
where we won’t have some form of historical Jesus studies, simply because Jesus
is too important of a historical figure for too many people. I agree entirely. Dagmar then, however, questioned what type of
work will be produced in the future in light of the seeming witch hunts that
take place in theological schools, particularly those in the States. She cited the recent turmoil at my and
Anthony’s former employer, and specifically Anthony’s dismissal, as
evidence. Her point was simple—What kind
of progress could possibly be made by people who must remain silent for fear of
losing their jobs? This is an important
question that I think evangelical Christianity must yet wrestle with, despite
the wrestling already passed.
In this context, I pass along two absolute
gems from Dagmar. She said at one point
that we must remember, “It is a quest and not a conquest. Never getting to the end of the journey
doesn’t mean we shouldn’t enjoy the hike.”
The second quotation I’ll pass along was her closing comment and I think
an equally important thing to remember:
“My heart is in the quest because it makes us able to talk to one
another.”
Saturday, September 8, 2012
Morna D. Hooker
Chris and I were over the moon when Morna D. Hooker agreed to write the foreword for our book (the related conference in Dayton, OH is now only a month away).
As is well-known, Professor Hooker wrote two essays (1970, 1972) criticizing the traditional authenticity criteria in Jesus research. Many, many scholars since have lamented the fact that they did not heed her warning earlier in their careers. Dale Allison says as much in his chapter of Jesus, Criteria, and the Demise of Authenticity. You can read Prof. Hooker's foreword here:
Our gratitude to the kind folks at T&T Clark for making this available.
The Jesus Blog has an online interview scheduled with Prof. Hooker in the coming months.
anthony
Friday, September 7, 2012
Barry Schwartz will be presenting in Dayton
I have just received very good news about our upcoming conference in Dayton. In addition to an utter embarrassment of wealth in Jesus scholarship present, we will also welcome the world's foremost expert on Social Memory theory, who also happens to be the most respected voice in the world on historiography related to Abraham Lincoln. If you've ever had the pleasure of hearing Prof. Barry Schwartz speak at SBL, you'll know that he is always brilliant, engaging, and is not shy about critiquing biblical scholars when he disagrees with them. I have often appreciated his relative optimism about how much historians are able to know about Jesus. In a field that is marked by idiosyncratic methodologies designed to obscure the Jesus of history, Prof. Schwartz is a breath of fresh air.
Thursday, September 6, 2012
You trying to say Jesus Christ can’t hit a curveball?
One of my favorite lines from the movie Major League involves a locker room dispute between two faith caricatures. Both caricatures are equally offensive, but it’s a movie about baseball, not Das Boot. Cerrano (Dennis Haysbert) says, “Jesús, I like him very much; but he no help with curveball.” His interlocutor replies, “You trying to say Jesus Christ can’t hit a curveball?”
Despite our many, many differences, Professor Keith and I
are both fond of this line as it represents a very quaint heresy. More on that in a moment.
As you might expect, the above link points you to Keith’s
recently published monograph. I could
say a few words about its importance, originality, and general awesomeness, but
nothing I could say would have more clout than Dale Allison’s foreword. Allison writes:
"...all subsequent discussions will inevitably take their bearings from Jesus' Literacy. The work is comprehensive, well-informed, and well-argued, and time and time again it reveals that almost everybody who has addressed the pertinent issues has come to premature conclusions... Indeed, it is no exaggeration to say that this book renders everything else written on this subject well-nigh irrelevant."
But not every person in the world was as excited
as Dale about this project. I happen to
know that Chris weathered a great deal of guff over his thesis. Indeed, it was a veritable guffstorm. Folks had a problem with Chris’ thesis that
Luke systematically places Jesus in a social class that was marked by scribal
literacy, while Mark does not. Folks had a problem with Chris’ thesis that Jesus
probably did not read the text from Isaiah (cf. Luke 4:16-30) in Mark's account. But the biggest guff-disturbing
issue was that Chris had the audacity to ask a question concerning Jesus’ literacy and that
he was willing to go wherever his research took him.
After all, asking the question assumes that you don’t
already have an answer. Of course Jesus
could read! He was the smartest man who
ever lived! If you want to be saved, you
have to ask Jesus into your heart and believe that he was the smartest man who
ever lived. Everybody knows this. Please forgive my sarcasm as I belittle a
very old heresy.
Wednesday, September 5, 2012
The Form-Critical Dependence of the Criteria of Authenticity - Chris Keith
In my introductory post I noted that,
before becoming fascinated with historical Jesus studies, I had been convinced
that they were passé. One aspect of that
prior conviction has been important for my subsequent work, especially as it
relates to the conference surrounding my and Anthony’s book Jesus, Criteria, and the Demise of
Authenticity.
Because of my work at the graduate level
with social memory theory (under Tom Thatcher), I believed intuitively that the
criteria of authenticity were really just “form criticism in disguise.” I believed this because of their assumption
that the gospel tradition was capable of being fragmented into bits of
tradition that either reflected the Sitz
im Leben Jesu or the Sitz im Leben
der Kirche. This, in my mind, was not
only a false choice but also simply a transferral of the form-critical
conviction that the gospel tradition could be broken into bits of tradition
that either reflected earliest Palestinian Christianity or later Hellenized
Christianity.
In passing, I made comments to several
people at SBL about this, including Rafael Rodríguez and Anthony Le Donne. They both listened to my statements in the
way that you do when someone is claiming something you don’t entirely buy but
you also don’t want immediately to shoot down in front of their face because it
would be rude—lots of “Hmmm, that’s interesting” with a sip of their drink and
no follow-up comment.
Tuesday, September 4, 2012
The One-Month Mark
TO PURCHASE THE BOOK RELATED TO THIS CONFERENCE, CLICK HERE.
The conference related to our book, Jesus, Criteria, and the Demise of Authenticity is officially one month away (Oct 4-5). Chris and I are grateful to United Theological Seminary in Dayton, OH and the University of Dayton for hosting this event.
Our hope is that this meeting will provide the most comprehensive discussion to date about the limits of the traditional "criteria for authenticity" in historical Jesus research. Considering the roster assembled, we can hardly miss. Dale Allison will reflect on his career in Jesus research and eventual disillusionment with the traditional criteria. Loren Stuckenbruck will discuss the severe shortcomings of the criterion of Semitic Influence. Jens Schroeter will discuss the philosophical problems at the roots of the "criteria approach" (a phrase coined by Chris Keith's recent ZNT essay). Chris Keith will point out the roots of the enterprise in form criticism (Chris will post more on this soon). Mark Goodacre will apply his expertise on the Synoptic Problem and Thomas to expose the problems related to "Multiple Attestation". Dagmar Winter, the foremost expert on the criterion of Dissimilarity, will share her thesis concerning "plausibility" in historiographical study. Rafael Rodriguez will argue that the criterion of Embarrassment is altogether bankrupt. I (the least of these [false modesty assumed]) will offer a modest critique of the criterion of Coherence and then throw a wrench into the whole works by suggesting that some of the traditional criteria might continue to be useful.
Monday, September 3, 2012
Chris Keith introduction
When Anthony Le Donne first approached me
about doing this blog together, my initial thought was: “Yes, that’s precisely what the world
needs—one more blog.” But after we discussed
it thoroughly, I became very excited about its contribution, or at least
potential contribution, to the scholarly landscape. The reason was simple. Whereas I think there’s a general conviction
among New Testament scholars that historical Jesus research has run its course
(and have heard multiple senior scholars state as much), or at least that this
stage of it has, I think otherwise.
Don’t get me wrong; I agree that much of the discussion as it stands is
regurgitated and worn. But I also think
there’s some fresh and exciting work being done and would cite examples such as
Dale Allison’s Constructing Jesus or,
if I may be so bold, my and Anthony’s multi-author volume, Jesus, Criteria, and the Demise of Authenticity. I am foolish enough to believe that there is
more fresh work to come and that the advent of memory studies especially may
have just ushered us into a new historiography with Jesus studies. This blog, as the only blog to my knowledge
that is specifically dedicated to Jesus research, will be a fantastic front-row
seat to these developments.
I have to confess that I am surprised that
I think this. My doctoral work did not
concern the historical Jesus and by the end of that stage of study I had
already come to believe that historical Jesus studies were passé. It was not until my monograph on the literacy
of the historical Jesus forced me to come back to Jesus studies that I realized
what potential there was in some of the fresher studies.
My other interests are in scribal and book culture,
textual criticism, media criticism, and social-scientific interpretation. I suppose I may veer into these topics now
and again as well as opportunities emerge, and as they relate to historical
Jesus research. I’m also pretty
fascinated with the significant shifts in higher education and how they are
affecting New Testament and Biblical studies.
As a native Louisvillian, I’ll also be veering occasionally into the
topic of University of Louisville basketball and football, and the accompanying
hatred of all things University of Kentucky athletics that goes with being a
Cardinal fan.
clk
About this blog
I’ve always dreamed of starting a blog about Jesus. While my
childhood friends were playing G.I. Joe and mumblety-peg, I would sit at home
and try out possible weblog layouts on my Etch A Sketch. Erstwhile, none of the girls would dance with me because
they were intimidated by my signed copy of E.P. Sanders' The Historical Figure
of Jesus. Still I pressed on with the hope that one day I might be able to
review books with Latin titles. So, when Chris Keith and I started discussing
this blog, I knew that a lifelong goal of mine was finally materializing. Take
that, Brenda Snaeffenschlogger! You may have passed me over for a taller dance
partner, but I am now a societal elite. That undersized wallflower swaying
alone to Time after Time has
blossomed into an aspiring blogger.
Here are the kinds of things you might find on this blog in
2012:
- Rough thoughts concerning Jesus - I will suggest that Jesus was a non-violent messianic prophet who believed in a warrior god. Chris will call me a dirty hippie and trot out an obscure verse from Luke 22. Oh, the fun we will have.
- Matters related to Jesus historians - I will write of my love for Joseph Fitzmyer and Chris will share some of his poetry dedicated to Martin Hengel.
- News and notes on the professional field of Jesus studies - we will discuss upcoming conferences, projects, and best practices in religious and historical studies.
- Reviews - I am embarking on a project that considers historical voices on Jesus that have been overlooked by most “Quest” surveys. I might review Harvey Falk’s Jesus the Pharisee or Thomas Jefferson’s collected letters / Bible. Chris will review only very expensive monographs that he can resell on Amazon.
Saturday, September 1, 2012
Anthony Le Donne Academic Bio
A few details about Anthony:
Anthony Le Donne is a visiting lecturer at the University of
the Pacific. He completed his Ph.D. at Durham University (England) in
2007. His research interests include historical Jesus, philosophy of
history, memory theory, Second Temple Judaism, and Jewish-Christian dialogue. His
books include The Historiographical Jesus: Memory, Typology, and the Son
of David (2009) and Historical Jesus: What Can We Know and How Can We Know
It? (2011). He is the co-editor (with Tom Thatcher) of The Fourth Gospel
in First-Century Media Culture (2011). He has published academic essays in New
Testament Studies and Journal for the Study of the Historical Jesus. Anthony’s forthcoming projects include studies in religious violence and
the apostle Paul. His home on the web is anthonyledonne.com.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



